back to IMPACT homepage

Impact - EC research project

investigation of extreme flood processes and uncertainty

investigation of extreme flood processes and uncertainty

Work programme EC Research Project:
Project Reference No. EVG1-CT2001-00037

To receive e-mail updates on project progress
Impact project team members only

WP 2: Breach Formation


1. Overview
2. Field Modelling of Embankment Failure
3. Laboratory Modelling of Embankment Failure
4. Numerical Modelling of Embankment Failure
5. Breach Location


1. Overview

The scope of work under this part of the IMPACT project covers 4 main areas. These are:

  • Field modelling of embankment failure (6m embankments)
  • Laboratory modelling of embankment failure (0.6m embankments)
  • Numerical modelling of embankment failure
  • Breach location

The objective of this work is to improve our ability to predict breach formation and breach location. The aim of the work is to provide large scale (field) data and smaller scale laboratory data against which numerical models may be tested and developed. Comparison of large and smaller scale tests also allows the investigation of scale effects and determination of the applicability of smaller scale (less expensive) laboratory tests.

For general enquiries regarding the Breach Formation work, please contact Mark Morris

Download WP2 programme

Back to top

2. Field Modelling of Embankment Failure

A series of 5 field tests will be undertaken at a test site in Norway. The site permits the construction of a 6m high, 30m wide embankment, retaining some 100,000m3 of water. This will then be breached under monitored conditions providing information on the breach formation process for a variety of embankment geometries and materials.

For more information on this work see:

Back to top

3. Laboratory Modelling of Embankment Failure

A series of 5 field tests will be undertaken at a test site in Norway. The site permits the construction of a 6m high, 30m wide embankment, retaining some 100,000m3 of water. This will then be breached under monitored conditions providing information on the breach formation process for a variety of embankment geometries and materials" for "To complement the field modelling, a series of 22 laboratory tests at 1:10 scale have been undertaken. These tests have been used to compare against and extrapolate the field data.

For more information on this work see:

4. Numerical Modelling of Embankment Failure

A programme of numerical (breach) model comparison and development has been established to use the field and laboratory data outlined above. The objective of the model comparisons is to identify model performance and the most effective approach to modelling breach formation. Comparison of model performance will be made through a series of controlled tests. Modellers will be asked to simulate failure of various embankment 'conditions' and results will be collated and subsequently compared against observed field or lab data.

Modelling is being undertaken by selected members of the IMPACT project team. However, the value of model comparison is significantly enhanced by additional participation in the modelling programme from modellers worldwide. Participation in this programme is open to any organisation. Field and laboratory data for the various embankment failure tests will be made freely available on the basis of participation in the modelling programme (i.e. submission of modelling results for comparison against other results).

In order to maintain an objective programme of model comparison, benchmark tests, datasets etc. are released to individual modellers to a predefined programme. We welcome wider participation in this programme.

For more information on this work see:

Back to top

5. Breach Location

The objective of this work package is to try and identify whether the likely mode and location of a breach in a long length embankment can be established in relative risk terms. This would allow owners of large lengths of flood embankment to prioritise maintenance works according to the risk of breaching. A tool or methodology for predicting relative risk/location will be developed.
The programme of work will include the following stages:

  1. Literature review to establish current stage of art with respect to factors affecting breach location
  2. Consultation with national bodies responsible for flood defence seeking case study material and information relating to location factors.
  3. Analysis of case study material. Identification of key contribution factors, their relative occurrence and relative importance in determining breach location.
  4. Development of a practical methodology for assessing the relative risk of breaching at a given location, or along length of flood defence embankment.
back to Work Programme
back to Top